Neither is stronger in every sense. Cold-rolled flighting is stronger in surface hardness and fatigue resistance because work hardening and a continuous weld-free helix reduce stress concentration. Pressed sectional flighting is stronger in section thickness and abrasive wear because it keeps full plate thickness and accepts Hardox, AR plate and manganese steel.
Surface Hardness Favors Cold RollingCold rolling plastically deforms the strip, and the material work-hardens during the process. The finished flight has a harder, smoother surface than the original strip. This helps resist moderate abrasion and gives stable pitch in standard service. A Continuous Screw Flight Cold Rolling Machine produces this work-hardened surface as part of the forming process.
The gain is a surface effect. The outer edge is also thinned during rolling, so the hardened layer sits on a thinner substrate at the wear zone.
Section Thickness Favors Pressed SectionalPressed sectional flighting starts as plate and keeps uniform thickness from root to rim. A 16 mm plate gives a 16 mm edge. More importantly, sectional construction accepts Hardox 400/450/500, AR plate and manganese steel, so the entire section can be made from a wear-resistant grade. In abrasive materials, this through-thickness property usually outperforms a work-hardened skin. A Spiral Blade Forming Machine set up for sectional pressing handles the forming step; the plate grade does the wear work.
Weld Integrity Cuts Both WaysCold-rolled helicoid is continuous, so there is no body weld to act as a fatigue initiator or corrosion site. Sectional flighting requires welding, and weld quality becomes a separate variable. A well-controlled weld is strong; a poor weld is the weakest point in the assembly. This is a process-control issue, not an inherent material disadvantage.
How to DecideIf the failure mode is surface wear in moderate abrasion, cold-rolled may be sufficient and more economical.
If the failure mode is thick-section wear in abrasive bulk handling, pressed sectional with a wear plate is the stronger choice.
If geometry varies beyond fixed-roll capability, a Winding Spiral Blade Forming Machine provides an alternative route. Define the failure mode before comparing quotations.
Contact: Lucy Chai | lucychai0315@gmail.com | www.refinerdisc.com | WhatsApp: +86 15373883537
Contact Person: Mr. Maple
Tel: +86 17778255675
Fax: 86--311-80690567