· ✔ An overband magnet works from the top of the burden downwards; a magnetic pulley only works on iron that is close to the belt surface.
· ✔ A magnetic pulley typically costs 40–60% less than a comparable self-cleaning overband, but its effective capture depth is limited to roughly 50–100 mm of aggregate.
· ✔ Overband installation usually fails on structure and headroom, not on magnetics — 500–700 mm of clear space plus a discharge chute is mandatory.
· ✔ Splitter plate position decides product loss on a pulley installation as much as field strength decides capture.
· ✔ Steel-cord belts short-circuit the pulley field and are a poor match for magnetic pulleys.
· ✔ Neither technology sees manganese steel, stainless or aluminium; a metal detector with a belt-stop interlock covers that gap.
· ✔ At 180 mm burden on a 1,000 mm belt, the overband is almost always the correct specification regardless of price.
· ✔ The cheapest total cost of ownership often comes from a pulley at a clean, thin-burden transfer point plus an overband on the dirty primary feed.
|
Feature |
Self-Cleaning Overband Magnet |
Magnetic Head Pulley |
|
Mounting position |
Suspended above the belt, at the head end or mid-span |
Replaces or sits inside the head pulley at the discharge |
|
Capture mechanism |
Lifts ferrous pieces up out of the burden |
Holds ferrous pieces against the belt past the normal trajectory |
|
Effective burden depth |
150–300 mm depending on field and gap |
Roughly 50–100 mm in practice |
|
Iron discharge |
Cleated belt carries iron sideways into a chute |
Iron drops behind a splitter into a reject chute |
|
Headroom required |
500–700 mm above the belt plus chute |
None above the belt |
|
Power demand |
0.75–2.2 kW drive (permanent); 5–12 kW/m width (electromagnetic) |
Zero — passive permanent magnet |
|
Indicative capital cost, 1,000 mm |
US$18,000–35,000 plus frame |
US$6,000–14,000 |
|
Best fit |
Deep burden, high tonnage, heavy iron load |
Thin even burden, tight headroom, pulley replacement due |
|
Main weak point |
Structure, headroom, discharge chute plugging |
Shallow reach, splitter sensitivity, lagging wear |
Customer type: Independent hard-rock quarry, 350 t/h two-stage crushing plant
Ore type: Granite, abrasive, blast-fragmented
Operating conditions: 1,000 mm fabric belt at 2.0 m/s, burden 160–200 mm, two shifts, outdoor installation
Problem: The plant had no magnet ahead of the secondary cone. Drill steel and bucket-tooth fragments reached the chamber roughly three times a year, each event costing US$15,000–20,000 in liners, labour and lost production. The maintenance team initially asked for a magnetic head pulley because it was the cheaper option on the quote.
Solution: A burden measurement at the proposed pulley position showed 180 mm of granite over the belt — well beyond the practical reach of a pulley. The specification was changed to a permanent rare-earth self-cleaning overband mounted on the secondary feed at a 280 mm gap, with a lined discharge chute and a metal detector with belt-stop interlock downstream.
Result: Captured iron averaged 5–8 kg per week in the first quarter, mostly drill steel and screen wire. No cone chamber event occurred in the following 14 months. The installed cost was US$41,000 including frame, chute and detector, giving a payback of under 12 months against the historical event rate. The plant later added a magnetic pulley at a thin-burden product conveyor for US$9,000, which was the correct use of the cheaper technology.
Q1: Do I need a self-cleaning overband or a magnetic pulley for aggregate crusher protection?
A: Base the decision on burden depth. Above roughly 100 mm, an overband removes more iron because it reaches into the bed; a pulley only sees iron at the belt surface. Below 100 mm with an even, single-layer burden, a pulley is cheaper and equally effective. Measure the burden before you compare prices.
Q2: Can a magnetic pulley remove iron buried in the material?
A: No. A pulley's field must pass through the belt and the full burden above it, and aggregate absorbs that flux quickly. Iron more than about 100 mm above the belt surface is usually beyond reach, and heavy pieces at depth are effectively invisible. That is a geometric limit, not a matter of buying a stronger magnet.
Q3: Can I fit a magnetic pulley to my existing conveyor without changing the frame?
A: Sometimes. The pulley must match face width, diameter, shaft diameter, bearing centres and take-up travel, and the drive must tolerate the slightly different inertia. A pulley that is larger than the original may also change the wrap angle and discharge trajectory. Always send the existing pulley drawing with the enquiry.
Q4: How much headroom does a self-cleaning overband need?
A: Plan on 500–700 mm above the belt for the magnet body, discharge belt and frame, plus a chute route to a bin. The suspension gap itself should be the largest lump plus at least 50 mm, and 200–300 mm is common for aggregate duty. Headroom is the most frequent reason an overband retrofit is abandoned after quotation.
Q5: Which one costs less to run?
A: A magnetic pulley, by a wide margin: no power, no cleated belt, no drive motor. Budget US$300–900 a year for lagging and bearings versus US$1,000–2,500 plus 3,000–15,000 kWh for an overband. The overband only wins on running cost when the pulley it replaces was letting iron through and crusher events were the real expense.
Q6: Will a magnetic pulley damage the belt or reduce drive traction?
A: Not on a correctly specified fabric belt. The pulley is a normal head pulley with magnets inside, and lagging is retained. Problems appear on steel-cord belts, where the cords are attracted to the magnets, the field is short-circuited and belt tracking can suffer. If your belt is steel-cord, specify an overband instead.
Q7: Can either device catch manganese steel or stainless steel?
A: No. Austenitic manganese steel is effectively non-magnetic, and stainless, aluminium and brass are invisible to any magnet. Only a metal detector with a belt-stop interlock covers these materials, and on a cone, hammer or impact crusher that interlock is not optional — it is the last line of defence.
Q8: What size magnetic pulley do I need for a 1,000 mm belt?
A: Face width typically runs 100–150 mm wider than the belt, and diameter is set by belt speed and the required discharge geometry rather than by magnet strength. Send belt width, speed, burden depth and the existing pulley drawing; sizing a pulley from belt width alone is how plants end up with a unit that fits but does not capture.
Q9: Can I install both devices on the same plant?
A: Yes, and on multi-stage plants it is often the best value. Put a deep-field overband on the dirty primary feed where buried heavy iron arrives, and a pulley at a clean, thin-burden secondary transfer where it costs a fraction of a second overband. Add a metal detector wherever non-ferrous metal could reach an expensive chamber.
Q10: What information do I need before requesting a quotation?
A: Belt width and speed, tonnage, maximum lump size, measured burden depth, the iron you are actually finding (with weights and the largest piece), available headroom, head pulley drawing if a pulley is being considered, site voltage, and a photo of the location. With those seven items a supplier can quote a specification instead of a box.![]()
The overband-versus-pulley question is not a brand question or a budget question; it is a measurement question. A magnetic pulley is an elegant, passive, inexpensive device that removes surface iron beautifully — and it cannot see through 180 mm of granite. A self-cleaning overband reaches into the burden, discharges continuously and costs two to three times as much, and on a deep-bed primary feed it is the only one of the two that does the job.
So measure the burden, count the iron, check the headroom and the head pulley, then choose. Where the burden is thin and the belt is fabric, buy the pulley and spend the savings on a metal detector. Where the burden is deep, the belt is steel-cord or the crusher behind it is expensive to stop, buy the overband and design the chute properly. And on any plant with more than one iron pathway, use both — the cheapest protection is usually the device that matches the geometry of the conveyor it sits on, not the device with the biggest magnet.
Contact: Annie Lu
Email: annie.lu@huataogroup.com
Phone / WhatsApp: +86 180 3242 2676
Website: http://www.tufflexscreen.com
We warmly welcome customers from around the world to contact us and establish mutually beneficial partnerships.
Contact Person: Mr. Maple
Tel: +86 17778255675
Fax: 86--311-80690567